A host of companies and patents linked to ANC spokesperson Pule Mabe were part of the extraordinary R49-million tender awarded by a subsidiary of the North West government.
Mabe, a former ANC member of Parliament, declared his directorship of Enviro Mobi and Kariki Media in the MPs register of members’ interests in 2016. These are the same companies that Mabe told City Press last year were subsidiaries of his Rivalox company, of which he was chairman.
These companies feature prominently in the multimillion-rand service level agreement signed between Mvest Trust and the North West Development Corporation (NWDC).
Mabe has denied any wrong-doing and any involvement in the deal except that he was a patent holder for an “Uber for laundry” app.
He told the Mail & Guardian he had resigned from Enviro Mobi in 2014 and Kariki Media in 2015.
It has now emerged that the corporation is investigating allegations of fraud into the payment of R49-million. The M&G understands that the corporation’s board is interrogating the actions of former acting chief executive officer Mike Mthimunye, who is believed to have unlawfully authorised the payment.
The service level agreement was signed by Mabe’s cousin, Eulender Rakoma, an Mvest Trust trustee. The other trustee is Mabe’s former business associate and employee, Tinyiko Mahuntsi. Mabe and Rakoma are said to be close, having grown up together. In the agreement Enviro Mobi is said to be an “invention enrolled as a patent and a service delivery management platform designed to enhance and improve service delivery”.
Kariki is a three-wheeler with a loader to collect and remove refuse, for which Mabe has a patent.
In legal correspondence with the M&G this week, Mabe pointed out that he had been advised by the trustees that the payments were made in two tranches within two weeks of the invoice being raised, and not within 48 hours as alleged last week.
Last week, Mabe distanced himself from Mvest, saying his relationship with the company was that of a “licensee and licensor”. But Mabe and the trustees of Mvest Trust appeared before a subcommittee of the corporation’s board in September 2017 to explain the work being done by the trust with regard to the project.
The trust was given the multimillion-rand contract as part of the youth enterprise project to create jobs in North West, even though it had apparently not produced a tax clearance certificate as required by treasury’s tax guidelines.
According to the treasury, accounting officers should ensure that people doing business with the state are tax compliant “at the date of submission and award of a bid”.
Mthimunye said yesterday that the tax clearance certificate was furnished by the trust when he effected its payment. “The tax clearance certificate was not requested at the time of signing of the SLA [service level agreement]; it was only requested on receipt of invoice and was presented prior to the payment being approved.”
This is despite the service level agreement being signed in April and Mvest Trust appointed without the project being put out to tender.
A source in the treasury said the corporation broke its own procurement processes. There should have been requests for proposals to test the market for the existence of other entities capable of providing the services.
[Wheel deal: Pule Mabe has the patent for the Kariki three-wheeler scooter, which was to have been used to remove refuse]
Last week Mabe did not deny indirectly benefiting from the project, saying he got an “incentive” as the app’s patent holder.
This week Mabe said he was never paid by Mvest Trust or the NWDC.
The app for which Mabe holds a patent was supposed to provide a laundry pickup and delivery service.
“This project was not about the development of an app and was about the development of an innovative enterprise platform, referred to as the youth enterprise combo. The execution of applications to facilitate the seamless operations of prospective beneficiaries was to happen in subsequent phases and customised for that purpose,” said Mabe.
But according to insiders there was no evidence of the app having been used. An independent tech expert this week tested the app but discovered that it was not functional. (See “Mvest laundry app will hang you out to dry”)
The payment, which the M&G revealed last week, was made by the corporation. The corporation is tasked with stimulating economic growth in North West province.
But the payment is alleged to have been made without following proper procurement processes. Mabe, an MP at the time, is said to have been intimately involved in the process but has strenuously denied any wrongdoing.
It was alleged last week that the payment was made within 48 hours of an invoice being submitted on June 14 last year. But it has now been established that the payment was made in two tranches — on June 23 and June 29 — to Mvest Trust, even though Mthimunye had no authority to approve such a payment because a chief executive had already been appointed on June 1.
“There was a CEO in that position. So we need to know what exactly was Mthimunye signing as and who gave him such authority,” said an insider at the corporation with intimate knowledge of the deal. “It amounts to fraud if people signed without being given any authority whilst there was a CEO appointed already.”
Mthimunye said he was still acting chief executive when he authorised the payment. “I was mandated by the current CEO to continue as acting CEO for the month of June 2017 while he was familiarising himself with the company and his new role. This was also announced to all NWDC staff in the staff meeting,” said Mthimunye.
The corporation’s board will meet on May 30 to discuss the investigation’s findings regarding the deal.
The corporation said that payment was made for services such as marketing, branding, recruitment, training, infrastructure arrangements, the activation processes and assets.
This is contrary to the service level agreement, which refers to laundry services, waste management, recycling and dry cleaning.
Mthimunye said Mvest Trust delivered on laundry services: “Mvest Trust renovated/constructed and equipped a laundry in Christiana. The laundry is fully operational,” said Mthimunye.
In his attempt to convince the M&G that work was done, Mabe last week produced pamphlets and brochures, which show that Mvest Trust had delivered on the contract.
Mvest laundry app will hang you out to dry
Following ANC spokesperson Pule Mabe’s assertion that the Mvest Clean app is like an Uber of a laundry pickup and delivery service, the Mail & Guardian asked a tech journalist to review the app.
The app is available on iPhone and Android. It is free to download but people must register first, with an email address, cellphone number and location.
It’s an on-demand service yet the app does not provide basic information such as a list of laundromats by location or prices.
Customers can send an order, using any location fed through Google Maps. But the only pickup time is between 8am and 10am.
There’s a payment option — either a credit card or your Mvest account. The last step is an option to edit or confirm the order.
The only feedback a customer gets is an automated reply from the company confirming the order. The email address used to confirm the order appears to be from the managing director of SovTech Product Labs, Andrew Chouler.
The app has basic menu options, with a profile page hidden under settings. But it lacks key components of an on-demand service, which gives the impression that the app was abandoned halfway through its development.
After asking for a pickup at 10am the next day, there was no further communication from Mvest, or from a laundromat nearby, which would have received our order.
But none of this matters. The company does not exist.
Mvest says it offers services “throughout South Africa”.
Yet the location tab lists a single location for Mvest in South Africa, an office at a shopping centre in Sunninghill, Johannesburg. When we called the company at this location — Sunninghill Laundromat & Dry Cleaners — they did not know about Mvest. The previous company at that location was called Pressed In Time, a well-established laundry franchise.
Furthermore, a visit to the website on the Chrome browser warns that the site is not secure, and that credit card or other sensitive information should not be entered. The website does not have prices listed.
The site states “we believe in creating jobs” but appears to confuse a vendor with a customer, and only offers application forms for those interested in becoming a franchisee. The app does not support vendor applications.
We recommend that you do not install this app. — Nafisa Akabor
In last week’s Mail & Guardian, we reported that Pule Mabe had resigned from Enviro Mobi in January 2018. That is incorrect. He had resigned from the company years before. The M&G regrets the error.